~ Originally Published December 21, 2016.
On December 21st, the Episcopal Church remembers Saint Thomas.
Thomas gets a bad rap but when it comes to the original Twelve Apostles, I think that he is probably my favorite.
Thomas wasn’t with Mary Magdalene in the garden, he wasn’t in the upper room with the other Apostles & he wasn’t on the road to Emmaus. So, when he started hearing these bizarre stories that Christ had somehow risen from the dead, he was skeptical, as any sane person should be.
Yet, he never said, “I don’t believe it.” or “I refuse to believe.”
Thomas said, “I will not believe, unless I can see where the nails pierced his hands, and touch the place where the nails had been, and put my hand where the soldier’s spear stabbed him.”
“I will not believe…unless…”.That is a stipulation that says, “There’s still a chance”.
So, Thomas was actually keeping an open mind while also setting a standard for proof. Look at the other accounts of the resurrection & notice that none of the witnesses immediately recognized the risen Christ. This is because, for some unexplained reason, and in some unspecified way, his appearance has changed. Considering this, it seems like Thomas is only being sensible.
“Ok, so you saw Jesus but you thought he was a gardener? And you didn’t touch him?”
“Ok, so you talked to Jesus for a couple hours but didn’t recognize him? And once you did recognize him, he just vanished into thin air?”
After the crucifixion, all the disciples must have felt a crushing, overwhelming depression. They had spent the last three years devoted to following Christ only to see it all come to a bloody, brutal end. Their hopes & dreams ended up being an epic, heart-breaking failure. But they
were devoted. They had given up their homes, families & money to be part of Christ’s ministry. He obviously offered them something special to make this seem like a worthwhile trade. So, I’m sure that deep down Thomas wanted nothing more than for Christ to be alive but how could that possibly be true?
In the 1st century, the idea that a person could be physically resurrected was a relatively new belief within Judaism & was quite controversial. However, Thomas knew that Elijah had brought a boy back from the dead & that Christ had brought Lazarus out of the grave. So, on some level, he had to believe it was at least possible.
In the 21st Century, when Christianity is too often watered down to sentimental drivel, what better example can we ask for than a saint who not only lives with hope but also demands empirical evidence & practices critical thinking?
If you can prove something is true with facts, then you don’t have faith, you have knowledge.
Conversely, blind faith isn’t really faith at all. There should be some solid reason to support your belief in the first place. Years later, Saint Paul would write, “work out your salvation with fear & trembling”… which means, this is so important that you must give it all your time, thought & energy. I think Thomas recognized this, that to be committed to Christ requires everything. And not only would it require everything from him but as an evangelist, he would need to explain to unbelievers why they might want to believe.
Thomas saw that this was too important to preach without backing it up with some evidence.
Faithfulness is not just some warm & fuzzy feeling that everything’s ok. That’s worldly happiness. That comes & goes. It’s nice but it’s temporary. Faithfulness is a deeper way of understanding the world.
Earlier in John’s Gospel, the disciples try to stop Jesus from going to Judea, where people want to stone him. Christ makes it clear that there is work to be done & no matter what his disciples say, no matter what the consequences turn out to be, Christ is going to Judea. Thomas is the first to step up & say, “Then let us go also, so that we may die with him.” This may seem fatalistic but I tend to take it as a sign of devotion. What he’s really saying is, if Jesus does die, at least he won’t die alone. Or maybe he was even gearing up for a fight by thinking, if they try to kill our friend, they’ll have to go through us to do it.
The phrase “Doubting Thomas” (much like “Patience of Job”) has wormed its way into our vocabulary & in doing so has lost its original context. In my opinion, doubt is not a sin. Doubt is not the same as disbelief. I think the same God who created the universe & the human mind gave us the gifts of curiosity & rational thought. Surely he is big enough to handle all our questions & doubts. I like to think that he even welcomes them.
When Christ shows up what does he do but offer himself to Thomas for examination?
“My Lord & My God!” What an amazing declaration of faith. Those are five little words but they contain volumes. I imagine that Thomas is so relieved, so happy, so overwhelmed, that Christ is really alive, that Christ is really Christ (!), that he must have the biggest lump in his throat & those five little words are all he can manage to choke out.
Christ never says Thomas was sinning but calls him blessed. Thomas is blessed because he has “seen & believed”… but that’s not all. Christ adds to that, “Even more blessed will be those who have not seen yet still believe.” He is talking about the rest of the world. He is talking about future generations, including ours. The holy catholic & apostolic church, against all odds, has continued to grow & thrive for thousands of years because of people like Saint Thomas, who devoted their entire lives to continuing the work of Christ.
Labels: Amateur Apologetics.